Horror game idea

Post Reply
User avatar
Mike
Posts: 4946
Joined: Tue Nov 24, 2020 11:17 pm

Horror game idea

Post by Mike »

Just mulling this over.

Premise: I use the email gaming format* of our old Paranoia games to run a horror game in which one person (or more) is the killer, trying to pick off the others.

*The email gaming format in question is that everything filters through me as GM. That is, everyone emails (or PMs) me what actions their character will be attempting. I put it all into a single cohesive narrative. Then I parcel it out and each player only gets the pieces of the narrative their character can see.

I don't have a setting yet (possibly a cabin in the woods 😊), but the killer could be amongst the players as a hidden traitor, or they could be some supernatural monster in the hills. I'm hoping it will be fun for the villain to play a real villain, and I'm hoping it will be genuinely creepy and scary for the others.

Things I would like to incorporate:
1. It would be cool to use my Mostly Dead/Horrified rules for action resolution. Maybe this can be another Discord game some day.

2. I'd like characters who are mostly tropes, stat-wise. Players can flesh them out and add flavor, but their strengths and weaknesses that they play from will usually match some horror stereotype.

3. I'd like some mechanism for keeping players in the game after their character is murdered. In a game where the bad guy is obvious, maybe dead protagonists get to keep playing as a new villain character. For example, in a Hills Have Eyes scenario, players who die get to take over yet another inbred cannibal who has come to join the party.** In a secret traitor game, though, players can come back as characters whose motives are unknown. Maybe they're the sheriff who arrives mid-movie to investigate, and they could really be a good guy, or they could potentially be in cahoots with the killer. DUN DUN DUN!

Okay, a lot of that doesn't quite work. If it's a secret identity game, and I get killed, I'm very likely to know who the killer is if I come back as another good guy. Hmmm. Needs work.

**There's a variation: There's a split of good guys and bad guys. When you die, you return as a character for the other team. First team to have all the players wins. Disadvantage is that I worry that with enough back and forth, it would lose its narrative focus and be more about the winning/losing.

Hmmm. Like I say, just a thought. If I can get a working plot and structure figured out in my head, maybe we'll make a go of this somewhere down the road. We'll see.
Any time the solution is "banjo rifle", I'm in 100%.
User avatar
Kyle
Posts: 5966
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2020 10:07 am

Re: Horror game idea

Post by Kyle »

I'm in.

I think that no one should know (except the villain) if the villain is among the players or not.

Players coming back (as bodysnatching aliens/zombies/ghosts) is a good idea. There's a ton of variants on this.
User avatar
Mike
Posts: 4946
Joined: Tue Nov 24, 2020 11:17 pm

Re: Horror game idea

Post by Mike »

I also want to keep the number of players to about 5.

I'll work on this.
Any time the solution is "banjo rifle", I'm in 100%.
User avatar
Tahlvin
Posts: 5010
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2020 9:34 am

Re: Horror game idea

Post by Tahlvin »

I'm in.
User avatar
Mike
Posts: 4946
Joined: Tue Nov 24, 2020 11:17 pm

Re: Horror game idea

Post by Mike »

Okay... I'm in. There will be an unknown number of players and NPCs. And I think I am full now. I have the basic form and function of "the adversary". The Adversary will be controlled by one of the players.

We will use the most recent variant of the Mostly Dead/Horrified rules. I'll post those somewhere soon.

I'm leaning to playing this one in Discord again. Instead of DMing me, I would create channels for each player that only they can see, plus a master narrative channel just for me. Then when it's over, I'll make them all public. Plus this gives me some extra options for the adversary.
Any time the solution is "banjo rifle", I'm in 100%.
User avatar
Eliahad
Posts: 1548
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2020 12:36 pm

Re: Horror game idea

Post by Eliahad »

Nice!
Post Reply