At least some subsection of the far right is distressed about his death and claiming it was a setup. I haven't the faintest idea why.
Re: RIP
Posted: Fri Jun 25, 2021 8:33 am
by Akiva
Stan wrote: βThu Jun 24, 2021 8:12 am
John McAfee, found dead in a Spanish prison.
Does it make me a bad person that I think it's incredibly appropriate that he died in a Spanish prison? I doubt he ever participated in the Spanish Prisoner scam, but it still seems fitting.
Stan wrote: βThu Jun 24, 2021 8:12 am
John McAfee, found dead in a Spanish prison.
Does it make me a bad person that I think it's incredibly appropriate that he died in a Spanish prison? I doubt he ever participated in the Spanish Prisoner scam, but it still seems fitting.
I hear you, and- for me- I don't want to celebrate the death of anyone. If I feel a sense of joy or schadenfreude over someone's death, I remind myself that I don't think that's okay.
But I think what you're saying is, "Hmmm. That seems about right." Which I think is totally okay.
Re: RIP
Posted: Wed Jun 30, 2021 4:23 pm
by Tahlvin
Donald Rumsfeld.
Re: RIP
Posted: Thu Jul 01, 2021 5:30 am
by poorpete
Gift of Gab passed last week
Re: RIP
Posted: Thu Jul 01, 2021 7:17 pm
by bralbovsky
I'm paraphrasing someone...I don't wish anyone dead, but I must confess I read some obituaries with pleasure.
The person who should have been president instead of various others who were.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 10:06 am
by poorpete
Hard agree. I was a big fan in my conservative teen youth. I hope he'd be known for what made him good, and also that he was probably the first black person in American history that could have been president if he wanted to (him or Oprah), and him supporting and advising Obama was hugely important for center-right people, who I disagree with but respect, mainly because I was once one, and they mostly mean well. I hope he'll be known for that over being used by neocons to pull a fast one over the UN.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 11:10 am
by Kyle
Colin Powell supported a war with no evidence, knowing there was no evidence. Thousands of people died, largely because he willingly lent his credibility to Bush and Cheney to go to war in Iraq. I never celebrate a death, but I also don't celebrate someone I don't respect just because they died.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 12:15 pm
by Phoebe
Kyle wrote: βMon Oct 18, 2021 11:10 am
Colin Powell supported a war with no evidence, knowing there was no evidence.
Honestly curious why people would think that, at the time, Powell himself thought there was no evidence? I've read some of these efforts to debunk his UN speech at the time as misinformation but I've never seen any persuasive evidence - indeed the evidence I've seen that supposedly proves he knew is many times weaker than the evidence he presented that was supposed to be bad evidence, like Powell's critics were not holding themselves to the same standards of evidence they expected from him at all. So if there is good evidence I would actually like to know.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 12:26 pm
by poorpete
My feeling has always been: Chalabi et al were liars who knew the evidence was false. Cheney and Rumsfeld either trusted Chalabi, he told them what they wanted to believe, or they knew it was BS but didn't care. They used Powell as a patsy.
Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson, later characterized Cheney's view of Powell's mission as to "go up there and sell it, and we'll have moved forward a peg or two. Fall on your damn sword and kill yourself, and I'll be happy, too."
Claiming that he was unaware that some intelligence officials questioned the information prior to his presentation, Powell pushed for reform in the intelligence community, including the creation of a national intelligence director who would assure that "what one person knew, everyone else knew
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 2:12 pm
by Kyle
Powell said he knew the evidence was not good enough for his regular standards, but felt tremendous pressure to give his UN speech. He also said that it was one of his biggest regrets. It should be. Without that speech it was likely the war wouldn't have been the scale it was. He holds responsibility. Are there bigger, more culpable actors? Absolutely. But he also holds the blood of thousands on his hands. It's hard for me to see this 24 hours of coverage of what a saint he was.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 3:21 pm
by poorpete
Failing to live up to his own high standards, sounds a lot like America.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 4:05 pm
by Kyle
Yeah. Rah Rah. America. That doesn't mean much to over 100,000 Iraqis who were killed in a war he pushed for. A war he went to the UN and said was necessary. A war he wanted to happen. Rah Rah.
Re: RIP
Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 9:04 pm
by bralbovsky
Powell was a model example of a "good Republican"
He seemed reasonable and measured, but harbored a deep cowardice about standing up against what he knew was wrong.
Let's say that at the time of the UN speech he believed the doctored photos were real. He had been lied to.
The day he found out, he perhaps didn't have the authority to call back the war machine, but he absolutely did have the power to find out who paid to have the evidence manufactured.
Instead, he kept his mouth shut.
He bears responsibility for every casualty of that war as if he fired the missiles or guns himself.
If he had attempted to really make reform, to hold those responsible for the fraud accountable, to exercise his considerable influence, then maybe I would give a shit that he is dead, or well intentioned.
Instead, he allowed it to occur, sugar coated it so as many as possible would swallow it, made it all seem justified and good.
All of the people in the previous administration who thought they were saving us by mitigating 45's psychosis, were really just giving it momentum.
Normalizing it, making at least parts of it ok, instead of allowing it to be crystal clear that it was evil.
That's Powell's legacy for me. He pretended Bush was competent and Cheney wasn't despicable. All while knowing he was a deep down fucking liar.
He would have been a terrible president.
He would have made very effective progress on terrible initiatives.
Re: RIP
Posted: Tue Oct 19, 2021 10:00 am
by Phoebe
Well, y'all do make a convincing case that he should have known or should have done something. I guess my problem is fundamentally, I mistrust the people he was working with and around so much more, that I find it quite believable Powell made at least decent decisions in those circumstances, was misled much of the time, and did what he could to take recourse. But I don't really know. Maybe he is just as responsible as people say and deserves the blame.
Maybe my blame assigner is flawed and distorted after adjusting to a world in which Liz Cheney has emerged as a hero of democracy, and many of that bunch of neocons from GW Bush on down have at least attempted distance from Trump. Arguably they built the very same dangerous political machine that now permits Trumpism to thrive and grow. Should I be as ready to assign responsibility to Powell for such things as I am to give it to others, recognizing that the naive hope he wasn't so bad as that is misplaced? Or was he really not as bad as that? It could be both.
I saw the headline on NPR before I jumped on NPR... And couldn't stop myself.
Re: RIP
Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2021 7:45 am
by Mando
RIP lots of people I disagreed with who did things I didnt sanction...but I am not gonna go pissin' on their graves. bad form.
Re: RIP
Posted: Fri Oct 22, 2021 5:15 pm
by Akiva
Peter Scolari
Re: RIP
Posted: Sat Oct 23, 2021 4:02 pm
by bralbovsky
Bad form notwithstanding...I've come to embrace that evil wins when good men do nothing, and anybody who isn't part of the solution is part of the problem, especially people with influence.
Re: RIP
Posted: Sat Oct 23, 2021 5:44 pm
by poorpete
I think Powell wouldn't be surprised that we'd all be talking about his greatest failure. I think his life will be studied for a long time... but definitely no one make a statue of him.
I had a weird experience when I read that Peter Scolari died. As I was looking at his name in print, I thought the words, βOh no! Rick Moranis died! Ohβ¦ waitβ¦ oh well that sucks too.β